Volume 3 Number
2
March 1991
#BIMONTHLY PROGRAM
#ELECTION RESULTS
#ANNUAL SPRING EQUINOX BASH
#CMC GOES CLIMBING IN BOLIVIA
#SPORTS MASSAGE
#FINAL WORDS FROM ABOVE
#Health Disturbances at High Altitudes: I
Magda is off to Gasherbrum II in May and plans to climb Makalu in 1992.
Don't miss the opportunity to hear one of CMC's own world class mountaineers
describe her adventures on this eight thousand meter peak. Program time is 7:00
PM at the CMC clubhouse.
So that the HAMS Section does not get to be a one person show, we will have
elections on an annual basis, probably at the January meeting each year. To
provide for a smooth transition of power, we will elect a Chairman-elect who
will serve as Chairman the following year. Election for this year's
Chairman-elect will be held at an upcoming meeting. Interested candidates
should contact Joe Fromme at the clubhouse address.
All good things must end some day, and so it is that my reign as Dalai Lama (or maybe that's Llama) of the High Altitude Mountaineering Section has ended. It has been a fun and rewarding experience getting the Section started, organizing two High Altitude Mountaineering Seminars, watching the HAMS School get off the ground, seeing several out-of-the-country expeditions take off and meeting so many of you who think hypoxia is fun.
While I've moved on to becoming the Chairman of the Denver Group, the Section has been left in the very capable hands of Joe Fromme. Joe is a long time mountaineer and very interested in high altitude climbing. He has ascended peaks in Europe and Nepal, and he just came back from the HAMS expedition to Aconcagua.
Assisting Joe will be a couple of handfuls of volunteers who do most of the leg work putting together the Thin Air newsletter, scheduling programs every other month, preparing educational offerings, compiling trip reports. arranging parties, keeping our database up to date and doing all of the other things that need to be done.
Now that I have "retired" from the Chairmanship, I can assume my new role of Elder Statesman of the Section. I can sit back and enjoy our programs without having to sweat whether the speaker will show up. I don't have to arrange Executive Committee Meetings. And. what I am really looking forward to, I no longer have to be the last one to leave and lock up the Clubhouse. Joe gets to do that now! -Dan Leeth
Health disturbances at high altitudes have been known and
recorded for centuries, but only in recent years has more attention been paid
to the causes, manifestations, effects and treatment possibilities. The basis
for this is the drastic increase in the number of people who, for recreational
purposes or the love of adventure, have risked great heights. In commercial
trekking groups to the Himalayas and the Andes, the average alpinist is
afforded the opportunity to stay longer at heights to which they are not
accustomed. Thus, the number of people who suffer from health impairments at
high altitude is on the increase.
Frequency:
Research in the Swiss Alps (Ref. 1) has shown that only
about 40% of mountain climbers are completely healthy at altitudes over 3500 m
(12000 ft), another 40% have altitude related health disturbances, and 20%
suffer acute mountain sickness. Results of studies in Nepal (Ref. 2) show that
at a height of 4200 m (14000 ft) 43% of those trekkers that were examined
showed symptoms of acute mountain sickness. Undoubtedly, it is a fact that
health disturbances at great heights lead to a higher probability of accidents
caused by errors in judgment and disorientation. This could be an explanation
for some of the unresolved catastrophes in high altitude climbing.
Classification and Symptoms:
The symptoms of high altitude disorders exhibit
considerable qualitative and quantitative variation from person to person. The
onset of health disturbances is estimated to begin at a height of 2500 m (8000
ft). The mildest form of health disturbance is "high altitude sickness" (Table
1). It makes itself felt through the appearance of one or more discomforts like
mild to moderately severe headache, sleeplessness, fatigue, exhaustion and loss
of appetite. Occasionally, at heights below 3000 m (9000 ft), swelling due to
fluid accumulation in subcutaneous tissue occurs before outward appearances can
be observed in facial and lower leg regions. These changes shall be referred to
as "peripheral high altitude edema" (= high altitude local edema, HALE). The
symptoms of high altitude sickness are harmless, to be sure, but have-a certain
warning character and therefore should be heeded.
| A. Altitude disturbances - Light to moderate headache - Sleep disturbances - Accumulation of watery fluids under the skin of the face and ankles (peripheral high altitude edema) B. Acute mountain sickness |
Causes:
Even though a large number of single factors have been suggested as causes for the previously described health disturbances, it has been proven that the interaction of several factors can significantly increase the risk of acute mountain sickness. One of the conclusive precursors for the development of high altitude health difficulties and high altitude edema is a too rapid ascent. Even experienced and fit mountaineers find that they are not immune to these problems if they fail to follow the guidelines of a slow ascent to high altitudes.
An additional factor that cannot be influenced by taking
the proper precautions is individual predisposition: even by following the
prescribed rules and appearing to acclimate normally some climbers tend to
repeatedly get sick. Normally the lack of oxygen at high altitudes has the
effect of stimulating breathing (hyperventilation) with the goal of maintaining
adequate uptake of oxygen. Extremely well adapted climbers exhibit highly
developed lung capacity in contrast to those that axe predisposed to pulmonary
edema (Ref 4).
Other factors in the development of pulmonary
edema are pressure and resistance changes in the lung's circulation. Lack of
oxygen, even in a healthy individual, leads to a narrowing of certain vessels
of the lungs and a resulting restriction in circulation. The result is an
increase of pressure of the lung circulation (pulmonary hypertension). Persons
who are known to have pulmonary edema problems have a stronger rise in pressure
in the lung tissues. Blood in areas of the lungs with restricted vessels gets
redistributed to areas that are less restricted. Currently, it is being
discussed if this redistribution causes a mechanical shearing action that
creates stress for the blood vessel walls. The result would be an increased
permeability of the vascular walls to protein-rich plasma. This fluid then
seeps into the surrounding lung tissues and then later into the lung air sacs
and creates the edema. It is further suspected that strong physical exertion
during the climb or after reaching the desired altitude (such as the digging of
snow caves) creates further oxygen depletion and contributes to the occurrence
of mountain sickness. Cold further increases the pressure in the lung cells.
Even though training is a requisite to high altitude activities it is no insurance that high altitude sickness will not occur. Lastly, the swelling that is observed in many mountain sickness patients and the decrease in urine output with a corresponding weight increase seem to suggest a change in hormonal systems.
Avoidance and Treatment
The most important preventive is the slow ascent to altitude (Table 2). Due to varying individual differences in ability to acclimate it is not possible to give a universal prescription.
It is recommended at elevations up to 4500 m (15000 ft)
to sleep no more than 300 m (1000 ft) higher than in the previous 24 hours
(Ref. 5). During the day greater elevation differences can be tolerated. Above
4500 m only 300 m increases should be done every other day.
It has been
proven favorable to have rest days at the same elevation. Always be aware of
the early warning signs such as peripheral edema, resting pulse rates that are
20% higher than experienced in valleys, as well as daily urine output that is
less than 1 liter. The following should guarantee adequate liquid intake: 1
liter per hour at strenuous physical exertion (Ref. 6).
A much discussed medication is Diamox [generic name
acctazolamide (Ed)]. It increases the breathing rate necessary at altitude and
if taken just before and during the first few clays of climbing it seems to
reduce the occurrence of symptoms (Ref. 7). It also may be dispensed in cases
of mild to severe symptoms of high altitude sickness. Diamox cannot replace a
proper acclimatization schedule! There are differing opinions in professional
circles on just how Diamox should be used during stays at high altitudes.
Referring to Table 2, what can be done in
cases of manifested symptoms? The safest measure to mitigate high altitude
symptoms is descent. Headache can be treated with aspirin or similar mild
painkiller. Sleeping pills are not recommended since they depress breathing
rates and favor the development pulmonary edema. Diamox can be tried in all
cases of high altitude health disturbances. Dexamethason leads to diminishing
of objective and subjective symptoms that are moderate to severe (Ref. 8); a
use that remains controversial in professional circles. At the appearance of
high altitude edema the treatment of choice is always evacuation of the climber
to lower regions. If oxygen is available it can be used in the context of first
aid but not as a substitute for evacuation.
| Slow ascent Rest days at attained altitude Diamox (controversial!) 250 mg every 8 hours beginning the day before start of climb and continuing at least for the first 5 days of the climb Treatment possibilities (from Johnson (Ref. 3)) Primary |
REFERENCES
1. B. Buhler, M. Walter, M. Maggiorini, O. Oelz: "Die Inzidenz und die
Erseheinungsformen der akuten
Bergkrankheit in den Schweitzer
Alpen" (in preparation)
2. P.H. Hackett, D. Rennie: "Rales, peripheral
edema, retinal hemorrhage and acute mountain
sickness," Am. J.
Med. 67, 214, 1979
3. S. Johnson, P. Rock: "Acute Mountain Sickness," New
Engl J. Med. 319 (13), 841, 1988
4. O. Oelz, H. Howard, P. DiPrompero, H.
Hoeppler, H. Claassen, R. Jenny, A. Biihlmann, G.
Ferretti, J.
C. Briickner, A. Veicsteinas, M. Gussoni, P. Cerretelli: "Physiological profile
of world
class high-altitude climbers," J. Appl. Physio. 60,
1743-1742, 1986
5. O. Oelz: "Prophylaxe und Therapie der akuten
Bergkrankheit," Therapeutische Umschau, 42, 52-57,
1985
6.
F. Berghold: "Bergmedizin heute," Bruckmann, Milnehen, 1987
7. P. Hackett:
"Medical therapy of altitude illness", Ann. Emerg. Med., 16, 980-896, 1987
8. G. Ferrazzini, M. Maggiorini, S. Kriemler, P. Biirtsch, O. Oelz:
"Successful treatment of acute
mountain sickness with
dexamethasone," BMJ, 294, 1380-1382, 1987
#Volume 3 Number 2 back to top